The job you are trying to view has expired. Please perform a new search to find current jobs.

Payroll Supervisor

Vista Care America, LLC -
Sheboygan, WI

Job Details

Full-time
$75,000 - $85,000 a year

Qualifications

Research
Supervising experience
Task prioritization
Managing accounting teams

Full Job Description

Job Title: Payroll Supervisor

Department: Payroll

Reports To: Director of Accounting Operations

Date: May 2026

Job Summary:

The Vista Care Payroll Supervisor oversees payroll operations and directly supports the accurate, compliant, and timely processing of payroll for our organization across multiple service lines and EINs. The role reports to the Director of Accounting Operations and is responsible for ensuring compliance with all federal, state and location payroll regulations and working closely with Human Resources & Finance departments to ensure accurate employee and payroll records. The Payroll Supervisor will manage a team of payroll specialists and collaborate across functions.

Duties/Responsibilities:

Supervises and manages the payroll team, ensuring payroll is processed accurately and on time.
Responsible for the training of new payroll team members; planning, assigning, and directing the work of the team in concert with the Director of Accounting Operations
Ensures compliance with applicable federal, state, and local payroll regulations.
Oversees the calculation of employee wages, bonuses, deductions, and benefits.
Conducts regular audits of payroll records and reports to ensure accuracy and completeness.
Troubleshoots and resolve payroll issues, including discrepancies and employee inquiries.
Prepares and submit reports related to payroll taxes, benefits, and other payroll-related activities.
Assists in the development and implementation of payroll policies and procedures.
Coordinates with the People Division to maintain and update employee records, ensuring all changes are accurately reflected in the payroll system.
Maintain up-to-date knowledge of payroll software and tools, ensuring the use of best practices.
Provides support for year-end reporting, including tax filings and W-2 preparation.
Liaise with external vendors, including tax agencies and benefits providers, to resolve payroll-related issues.
Other duties as assigned

Alignment with Core Values:

Being a positive role model for individuals, co-workers, and management.
Representing the company in a professional manner.
Complying with company policies and procedures.
Treating employees, management, and individuals with dignity and respect, including honest and respectful communication.
Focusing on official business during work hours.
Contributing to a harmonious working environment and maintaining strong relationships with co-workers, management, individuals, and external agencies.

Qualifications and Experience:

2+ years of supervisory experience successfully managing multiple team members in both remote and onsite environments
3+ years of experience in payroll processing
Payroll certification (FPC, CPP), preferred
Experience with payroll software such as UKG (Ultimate Kronos Group) is strongly preferred
Familiarity with payroll tax regulations, labor laws, and benefits administration- multi-state experience preferred
Demonstrated ability to work with complex payroll data sets
Experience with Netsuite preferred
Experience with import/export of data and data templates

Knowledge, Skills, and Abilities:

Strong attention to detail and accuracy.
Effective verbal and written communication skills
Fluency in oral and written English
Exceptional mathematical and calculation skills
Knowledge of garnishment and child support calculations
Competency in payroll tax regulations, labor laws, and benefits administration
Good research and analysis skills
High level of organization and time management.
Comfortable working both independently and as part of a team, with strong ability to manage competing priorities and meet deadlines
Proficiency in Microsoft Office Suite, especially Excel.
Must have good interpersonal skills and consistently demonstrate effective decision-making abilities
Flexible, adaptable, detail-oriented, and self-motivated

Additional Requirements:

Must pass WI BID and other background checks upon hire.
Completion of E-Verify process

Education:

Bachelor’s degree in Accounting, Finance, Business Administration, or a related field preferred. Will consider experience and/or certification in lieu of a formal degree program.

Working Conditions/Physical Requirements:

Physical Requirements – Requires manual dexterity and use of standard office equipment. Must be able to sit, walk, bend, and use a computer for extended periods.

Vision/Hearing/Communication – Must have corrected vision and hearing within normal range with or without reasonable accommodation. Must be able to communicate verbally and in writing with all staff, other professionals, and individuals. Must be able to give and receive verbal and written instructions in English.

Work Location – Full-time, onsite preferred at Vista Care Headquarters. Hybrid options may be considered.

#IND100

Job Seeker Tools

Employer Tools

Browse

Stay Connected