Looking for more than just another underwriting role?
If you’re an experienced commercial P&C underwriter who values relationships, purpose-driven work, and a collaborative environment, you might feel right at home here.
At the United Church Insurance Association (Insurance Board), we’re not just underwriting policies - we’re supporting communities. Our work helps protect churches and faith-based organizations across all 50 states, and we take that mission seriously.
What You’ll Do
As a Commercial Property & Casualty Underwriter II, you’ll play a key role in managing and growing a multi-state book of business. You’ll partner closely with agents and teammates to deliver smart underwriting decisions, exceptional service, and long-term value.
In this role, you will:
- Underwrite and manage a diverse portfolio of commercial P&C business
- Build strong, trusted relationships with independent agents
- Collaborate with a supportive team to drive retention and profitable growth
- Provide thoughtful, tailored solutions to meet the unique needs of our participants
What You Bring
You’re both analytical and relationship-focused, with a genuine commitment to service.
We’re looking for:
- 5–7 years of commercial P&C underwriting experience
- A bachelor’s degree (or equivalent experience)
- Professional designations such as AU, ARM, CPCU, CIC (preferred)
- Excellent communication, negotiation, and presentation skills
- Strong organizational and analytical abilities
- A collaborative, customer-first mindset
Who We Are
Insurance Board is a growing, mission-driven nonprofit risk-sharing program—created by churches, for churches. Today, we serve 4,400+ participants nationwide, offering specialized insurance coverage, risk management resources, and educational support tailored to faith-based communities.
We’re proud of our purpose, and equally proud of the culture we’ve built: inclusive, supportive, and people-centered.
Why Join Us?
We believe great work happens when people feel valued and supported. That’s why we offer:
- Competitive compensation
- Comprehensive benefits (health, dental, vision, life)
- Retirement plan
- Generous paid time off
- Flexible spending accounts
- Employee assistance program
- Professional development opportunities
- Hybrid work schedule (1 day/week in-office)
Ready to Make an Impact?
If you're looking for meaningful work, a collaborative team, and the chance to grow your career in a mission-driven organization, we’d love to connect.
Apply today by submitting your resume and cover letter to our Human Resources team.
Job Type: Full-time
Pay: $62,500.00 - $67,500.00 per year
Benefits:
- Dental insurance
- Employee assistance program
- Flexible spending account
- Health insurance
- Life insurance
- Paid time off
- Professional development assistance
- Retirement plan
- Vision insurance
Experience:
- Commercial Property and Liability Underwriting: 5 years (Required)
Work Location: Hybrid remote in Cleveland, OH 44113
