Top 21 Underwriter manager Jobs in Columbus

Manager, Underwriter
CVS Health —Columbus, OH
- $60,300 - $145,860 a year
- Full-time
- Mid-level
- Office
- Analysis skills
- Health insurance
- Dental insurance
Representative, New Business Support - Life
Nationwide —Grandview Heights, OH
- 8 hour shift
- Hybrid work
- Office
- Finance
- Bachelor's degree
- Paid holidays
- Disability insurance
1d
Relationship Manager
KEMBA Financial Credit Union —Columbus, OH
- $95,000 - $120,000 a year
- Full-time
- Hybrid work
- Mid-level
- Analysis skills
- Experience equivalent to degree accepted
Quick Apply
Commercial Lines Underwriting Specialist- Inland Marine (hybrid/remote)
Grange Insurance Company —Columbus, OH
- Remote
- 5 years
- Business development
- Bachelor's degree
- Bereavement leave
Credit Officer, CRE
S&T Bank —Hilliard, OH
- $75,000 - $184,800 a year
- Full-time
- Hybrid work
- Office
- Business development
- Bachelor's degree
Commercial Underwriter III
First Financial Bank —Worthington, OH
- $74,000 - $98,000 a year
- Full-time
- Office
- Finance
- Master's degree
- Paid training
Loan Officer
Ruoff Mortgage —Columbus, OH
- Full-time
- Office
- High school diploma or GED
- Organizational skills
- Paid holidays
- Health insurance
Commercial Lines Auto Products Director (hybrid/remote)
Grange Insurance Company —Columbus, OH
- Remote
- Analysis skills
- Bachelor's degree
- Team management
- Bereavement leave
11d
Management Liability Practice Leader
Insurance Office of America, Inc. —Columbus, OH
- $150,000 - $200,000 a year
- Full-time
- 5 years
- Senior level
- Communication skills
Quick Apply
2d
Group Employee Benefits Consulting Manager
Accenture —Columbus, OH
- $87,400 - $293,800 a year
- Full-time
- Bachelor's degree
- Team management
- Mentoring
- Paid holidays
- Disability insurance
Underwriting Consultant, National Accounts Property
CNA Insurance —Westerville, OH
- $72,000 - $141,000 a year
- Full-time
- Hybrid work
- 3 years
- Experience equivalent to degree accepted
- Senior level
Senior Loan Specialist
M/I Homes —Columbus, OH
- Weekends as needed
- Customer service
- Writing skills
- Mid-level
- Profit sharing
- Paid parental leave
Quick Apply
VP, Specialty Product Line
Liberty Mutual —Columbus, OH
- $179,000 - $322,000 a year
- Full-time
- Remote
- Office
- Bachelor's degree
- Travel
11d
Underwriting Consultant - Contract Surety
CNA Insurance —Westerville, OH
- Full-time
- Hybrid work
- 8 years
- Analysis skills
- Experience equivalent to degree accepted
Commercial Loan Underwriter
Telhio Credit Union —Columbus, OH
- Background check
- Pass drug screening
- Mid-level
- Paid parental leave
- Paid holidays
Quick Apply
MGA Contract Binding/Production Underwriter - Property & Casualty
USI Holdings Corporation —Columbus, OH
- Contract
- Mid-level
- 3 years
- Recruiting
- Health savings account
- Paid holidays
Associate, Direct Lending
Golub Capital —London, OH
- Full-time
- Hybrid work
- Word processing
- Research
- Office
- Health insurance
Portfolio Manager II or III
Northwest Bank —Columbus, OH
- $61,500 - $110,000 a year
- Full-time
- Research
- Mid-level
- Office
Quick Apply
CRE Portfolio Manager II or III
Northwest Bank —Columbus, OH
- $61,500 - $110,000 a year
- Full-time
- Research
- Office
- Finance
Quick Apply

Discover related jobs

Based on your search for underwriter manager jobs.

Analyst, Underwriting
US AMR-Jones Lang LaSalle Americas, Inc. —Columbus, OH
Attend and participate in deal team calls both internally and externally with Borrower representatives. Participate in training programs to include, but not…
$60,000 - $80,000 a year
Quick Apply
5d
FHA Sr. Underwriter – MAP (Commercial Real Estate)
KeyBank National Association —Columbus, OH
Pursue and develop internal and external relationships to facilitate effective real estate transactions and support the line of business strategy.
$96,000 - $181,000 a year

Explore jobs in cities nearby

Check out jobs in cities near your current location, Columbus

Manager, Underwriter
CVS Health —Columbus, OH
Qualified applicants with arrest or conviction records will be considered for employment in accordance with all federal, state and local laws.
$60,300 - $145,860 a year
Representative, New Business Support - Life
Nationwide —Grandview Heights, OH
Assists with the processing and customer service of new life insurance applications, including data entry, document verification, and agent calls.
1d

Show more jobs in cities nearby

I want to receive the latest job alert for underwriter manager in columbus

By signing in to your account, you agree to SimplyHired's Terms of Service and consent to our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

Explore jobs in more locations

underwriter manager jobs near columbus

Senior Portfolio Manager jobs in Columbus, OH

Underwriter jobs in Columbus, OH

Relationship Manager jobs in Columbus, OH

Shift Leader jobs in Columbus, OH

Employee Benefits Account Manager jobs in Columbus, OH

Underwriting Manager jobs in Columbus, OH

Chief Credit Officer jobs in Hilliard, OH

Loan Officer jobs in Columbus, OH

Senior Loan Specialist jobs in Tempe, AZ

Senior Loan Specialist jobs in Shakopee, MN

Senior Loan Specialist jobs in Houston, TX

Senior Loan Specialist jobs in Remote

Senior Driver jobs in Philadelphia, PA

Mortgage Loan Officer jobs in Nashville, TN

Senior Portfolio Manager jobs in Newport Beach, CA

Senior Portfolio Manager jobs in Phoenix, AZ

School Operations Manager jobs in New York, NY

Customer Success Manager jobs in Florida

Senior Portfolio Manager jobs in Seattle, WA

Senior Portfolio Manager jobs in Remote

Manager, Underwriter

CVS Health -
Columbus, OH

Apply Now

Job Details

Full-time
$60,300 - $145,860 a year

Benefits

Health insurance
Dental insurance
Paid time off
Vision insurance

Qualifications

Term negotiation
Team leadership
Team development
Salesforce Cloud
Health insurance knowledge
Mentoring
Sales management systems proficiency
Leading team collaboration initiatives
CRM system proficiency
Productivity software
Excel data analysis
Team building

Full Job Description

We’re building a world of health around every individual — shaping a more connected, convenient and compassionate health experience. At CVS Health®, you’ll be surrounded by passionate colleagues who care deeply, innovate with purpose, hold ourselves accountable and prioritize safety and quality in everything we do. Join us and be part of something bigger – helping to simplify health care one person, one family and one community at a time.

Position Summary

This Underwriting role is for Meritain Health, an independent subsidiary of Aetna and CVS, and one of the nation's largest employee benefits administrators. We have the resources of a national carrier coupled with the unique flexibility and devoted service of a third-party administrator (TPA).

The Meritain Health underwriting department supports the attainment of organizational goals through the issuance of prospective and existing business quotations and proposals. Including administrative fee pricing, stop loss, RFP questionnaire responses, and plan consultation.

The Underwriting Manager serves as a key support role within the Meritain Underwriting team, providing day-to-day management and mentorship to a group of underwriters. This position plays an important role in helping drive consistency and collaboration across the unit. The ideal candidate will bring a strong sense of ownership, the ability to work independently, and a proactive approach to problem-solving. This role is well-suited for someone who enjoys supporting others, contributing to process improvements, and serving as a go-to resource for both internal partners and external stakeholders.

Responsibilities

Team Leadership & Development

Proactively manage the workflow and shifting priorities of the underwriting unit to ensure timely, accurate deliverables.
Provide daily support, coaching, and mentorship to a team of underwriters, fostering skill development and professional growth.
Conduct quality reviews, identify learning opportunities, and oversee training for both internal staff and external stakeholders.
Lead team meetings and serve as the first point of contact for complex case issues or challenges.
Support hiring, onboarding, and ongoing talent development of direct reports.
May provide coverage for the department leader as needed.

Underwriting & Risk Assessment

Assists in preparing underwriting analysis and risk assessment for new and renewal business, including cases with significant benefit implications.
Assists in the preparation of quotes, questionnaires, and financial projections of varying complexity.
Apply underwriting guidelines and negotiate financial terms within assigned authority; escalate exceptions and financial variances to senior leadership as appropriate, balancing membership, revenue growth, and profitability.
Ensure pricing strategies align with business objectives and client needs.
Assist team members in navigating complex or sensitive sales and renewal situations.

Collaboration & Communication

Act as the central contact for final rate submissions (Final & Firm process), including reporting and coordination with underwriters and operational teams.
Collaborate with Business Analysis, Sales, Client Management, and other internal stakeholders to support sales and retention efforts.
Present underwriting information and explain rate development, underwriting policies, and product standards to internal and external stakeholders.
Build and maintain relationships with stop loss carriers to support case resolution and negotiation efforts.
Clearly articulate Meritain’s services, underwriting philosophy, and new initiatives to internal and external stakeholders.

Process Improvement & Strategic Support

Lead or contribute to departmental projects and continuous improvement initiatives aimed at enhancing productivity, accuracy, and customer service.
Identify and implement opportunities for automation and operational efficiency; influence the development of tools and resources.
Support the use and optimization of underwriting tools, systems, and reporting platforms.
Provide strategic input on stop loss placement, pricing, and product positioning.

Subject Matter Expertise

Demonstrate deep knowledge of Meritain’s product portfolio, underwriting philosophy, and market positioning.
Support the development of proposals that align with client goals and organizational strategies.
Analyze operational data and apply insights to financial modeling and fee development.
Serve as a trusted resource for internal partners on underwriting and stop loss strategy.

In order to be successful in this role you must exhibit the following:

Strong analytical, decision-making, and communication skills.
Demonstrated ability to lead, mentor, and/or develop team members.
Demonstrated success in anticipating customer needs and negotiating using tact and diplomacy
Proficiency in Excel, Salesforce, and Microsoft Office.
Ability to work independently and manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment.

Required Qualifications

5+ years of experience in underwriting, financial analysis, pricing methodologies, and/or funding arrangements.
2+ years of relevant medical insurance experience: brokers (producers), carriers, (TPA) third-party administrators, benefit analysis, underwriting, rating methodologies, or policy marketing, etc.

Preferred Qualifications

2+ years of prior leadership experience.
Salesforce, Tableau, and/or VBA experience.
Experience communicating with outside consultants or customers.

Education

Bachelor's degree required or equivalent years of related experience.

Anticipated Weekly Hours

Time Type

Full time

Pay Range

The typical pay range for this role is:

$60,300.00 - $145,860.00

This pay range represents the base hourly rate or base annual full-time salary for all positions in the job grade within which this position falls. The actual base salary offer will depend on a variety of factors including experience, education, geography and other relevant factors. This position is eligible for a CVS Health bonus, commission or short-term incentive program in addition to the base pay range listed above.

Our people fuel our future. Our teams reflect the customers, patients, members and communities we serve and we are committed to fostering a workplace where every colleague feels valued and that they belong.

Great benefits for great people

We take pride in offering a comprehensive and competitive mix of pay and benefits that reflects our commitment to our colleagues and their families.

This full‑time position is eligible for a comprehensive benefits package designed to support the physical, emotional, and financial well‑being of colleagues and their families. The benefits for this position include medical, dental, and vision coverage, paid time off, retirement savings options, wellness programs, and other resources, based on eligibility.

Additional details about available benefits are provided during the application process and on Benefits Moments.

We anticipate the application window for this opening will close on: 08/28/2026

Qualified applicants with arrest or conviction records will be considered for employment in accordance with all federal, state and local laws.

Apply Now

Refine Your Search

underwriter manager jobs in columbus

Manager, Underwriter

Representative, New Business Support - Life

Relationship Manager

Commercial Lines Underwriting Specialist- Inland Marine (hybrid/remote)

Credit Officer, CRE

Commercial Underwriter III

Loan Officer

Commercial Lines Auto Products Director (hybrid/remote)

Management Liability Practice Leader

Group Employee Benefits Consulting Manager

Underwriting Consultant, National Accounts Property

Senior Loan Specialist

VP, Specialty Product Line

Underwriting Consultant - Contract Surety

Commercial Loan Underwriter

MGA Contract Binding/Production Underwriter - Property & Casualty

Associate, Direct Lending

Portfolio Manager II or III

CRE Portfolio Manager II or III

Discover related jobs

Explore jobs in cities nearby

I want to receive the latest job alert for underwriter manager in columbus

Explore jobs in more locations

Job Seeker Tools

Employer Tools

Browse

Stay Connected