Top 14 Personal injury paralegal Jobs in Milwaukee Wi

Lead Paralegal
Nicolet Law —Milwaukee, WI
- Full-time
- Microsoft Excel
- Microsoft Outlook
- Continuous improvement
- Free parking
- Disability insurance
Quick Apply
5d
Paralegal/Legal Assistant
Gruber Law Offices —Milwaukee, WI
- $25 - $30 an hour
- Full-time
- Background check
- Research
- In-person
- Free parking
- Health insurance
Legal Assistant
Hupy and Abraham S C —Milwaukee, WI
- From $21 an hour
- Full-time
- Microsoft Outlook
- Office
- Administrative experience
- Health savings account
- Paid holidays
Quick Apply
11h
Personal Injury Litigation Paralegal- REMOTE/WFH
Parnall Law —Milwaukee, WI
- $58,260 - $74,900 a year
- Full-time
- Remote
- Background check
- 5 years
- Travel
- Paid holidays
- Disability insurance
Quick Apply
Paralegal - Spanish Speaker
Bykhovsky Law LLC —Glendale, WI
- $23 - $26 an hour
- Full-time
- Spanish
- Research
- Office
- Free parking
- Dental insurance
Quick Apply
2d
Paralegal
THE LAW OFFICES OF KANNER AND PINTALUGA PA —Milwaukee, WI
- Full-time
- Microsoft Excel
- Microsoft Outlook
- Mid-level
- Paid holidays
- Health insurance
Quick Apply
10d
Personal Injury Paralegal (3-5 years experience required)
MacGillis Law Group, LLC —Elm Grove, WI
- $50,000 - $70,000 a year
- Full-time
- Mid-level
- Office
- 3 years
- Free parking
- Disability insurance
Quick Apply
12d
Paralegal - WI
Sobo & Sobo, LLP —Milwaukee, WI
- From $47,000 a year
- Full-time
- Mid-level
- Office
- Bachelor's degree
- Health savings account
- Paid holidays
Quick Apply
13d

Other jobs to consider

Find your next job by exploring related positions.

Lead Paralegal
Nicolet Law —Milwaukee, WI
Associate's degree in paralegal studies, a paralegal certificate, or a bachelor’s degree in any field preferred.
Quick Apply
5d
Paralegal/Legal Assistant
Gruber Law Offices —Milwaukee, WI
You will prepare and review all documents related to the case while working closely with the attorneys to navigate each case and reach the best resolution for…
$25 - $30 an hour

Show more related jobs

Explore jobs in cities nearby

Check out jobs in cities near your current location, Columbus

Personal Injury Paralegal
Geiser & Bowman, LLC —Columbus, OH
401(k) with employer matching. Utilize case management software to document and track case activity. Draft correspondence, demand packages, and legal documents.
Quick Apply
Paralegal/Legal Assistant
Robenalt Law —Columbus, OH
Docketing, ordering medical records and bills, drafting pleadings, answering discovery and preparing cases for trial. High school or equivalent (Preferred).
$45,000 - $57,500 a year
Quick Apply

Show more jobs in cities nearby

I want to receive the latest job alert for personal injury paralegal in milwaukee wi

By signing in to your account, you agree to SimplyHired's Terms of Service and consent to our Cookie and Privacy Policy.

Explore jobs in more locations

personal injury paralegal jobs near milwaukee wi

Lead Paralegal

Nicolet Law
Milwaukee, WI

Quick Apply

Job Details

Full-time
5 days ago

Benefits

Free parking
Disability insurance
Health insurance
Dental insurance
401(k)
Flexible spending account
Paid time off
Parental leave
Vision insurance
Life insurance
Retirement plan

Qualifications

Customer communication
Microsoft Excel
Microsoft Outlook
Caseload management
Paralegal Studies
Continuous improvement
Client management
Productivity software
Legal case management
Paralegal Certificate
Professional development training

Full Job Description

The Lead Paralegal is a supervising paralegal responsible for maintaining an active caseload while training, coaching, and mentoring paralegals on the firm's personal injury workflows, procedures, and best practices.

The Lead Paralegal works closely with attorneys and firm leadership to manage workloads, ensure compliance with firm standards, drive operational efficiency, and support the continued growth and success of the legal teams. Incoming legal support staff assigned to support the Lead's caseload receive hands-on instruction and development through daily casework, guided training, and ongoing feedback.

The ideal candidate is an experienced personal injury paralegal with demonstrated leadership abilities and a passion for developing others through mentorship and training. They are a proactive and effective people leader who can balance case management responsibilities with team supervision, coaching, and performance development. They lead by example, provide constructive feedback, and create an environment where team members can grow professionally. They embody the firm's core values—We Care, We Win, and We Never Stop Getting Better—and help cultivate a positive, engaged, and high-performing culture. As a trusted resource and mentor, they work to strengthen team effectiveness, support employee growth, and ensure the consistent delivery of exceptional service to clients.

Team Leadership and Management

Supervise, mentor, and support paralegals, legal assistants and legal support staff assigned based on region.
Conduct performance evaluations and provide ongoing coaching and feedback.
Assist HR and leadership with recruitment, onboarding, and training of new team members as needed.
Address employee issues with Human Resources as needed.
Monitor productivity and identify opportunities for improved efficiency.
Collaborate with attorneys and department leaders to improve operational effectiveness.
Develop and implement best practices, workflows, and procedures for the legal department in accordance with leadership as needed.

Caseload Management & Staff Development

Maintain and manage an active personal injury caseload in accordance with firm standards and performance expectations.
Perform all core paralegal functions, including case management, client communication, medical record review, demand preparation, litigation support, and settlement coordination.
Work directly with assigned paralegals and legal support staff who assist with the Lead's caseload as part of their hands-on learning and development.
Delegate appropriate case tasks and provide real-time coaching, instruction, and feedback to support employee growth and skill development.
Utilize active case assignments as training opportunities to demonstrate best practices, effective case management, and quality client service.
Review work completed by assigned team members and provide guidance to ensure accuracy, consistency, and compliance with firm standards.
Foster a collaborative team environment that encourages learning, accountability, and professional development.
Reinforce and train on the firm's culture, expectations, and standards through onboarding, coaching, and daily interactions.
Act as a positive and welcoming point of contact for new hires, helping them acclimate to the firm, build confidence in their roles, and successfully integrate with their teams.

Qualifications:

Associate's degree in paralegal studies, a paralegal certificate, or a bachelor’s degree in any field preferred
7+ years cumulative legal experience (personal injury experience preferred but not required)
Demonstrated success managing a substantial caseload including litigation files
Experience mentoring, training, coaching, leading, or onboarding paralegals and legal support staff
Ability to effectively prioritize and balance an active caseload with training and development responsibilities
Excellent verbal and written communication skills, with the ability to explain complex concepts in a clear and supportive manner
Strong organizational skills, attention to detail, and commitment to quality work product
Proficiency in case management software and Microsoft Office Suite
Ability to build positive working relationships across all levels of the organization
Commitment to professionalism, client service, teamwork, and continuous improvement
Serves as a positive ambassador of the firm's culture and professional standards

Job Type: Full-time

Benefits:

401(k)
Dental insurance
Disability insurance
Flexible spending account
Free parking
Health insurance
Life insurance
Paid time off
Parental leave
Retirement plan
Vision insurance

Application Question(s):

Have you previously applied to Nicolet or worked with us in the past?
Were you referred to Nicolet by a current employee / do you know any current employees of Nicolet?
Are you a current or past client of ours?

Experience:

Legal: 4 years (Required)

Work Location: In person

Quick Apply

Refine Your Search

personal injury paralegal jobs in milwaukee wi

Lead Paralegal

Paralegal/Legal Assistant

Legal Assistant

Personal Injury Litigation Paralegal- REMOTE/WFH

Paralegal - Spanish Speaker

Paralegal

Personal Injury Paralegal (3-5 years experience required)

Paralegal - WI

Other jobs to consider

Explore jobs in cities nearby

I want to receive the latest job alert for personal injury paralegal in milwaukee wi

Explore jobs in more locations

Job Seeker Tools

Employer Tools

Browse

Stay Connected